Table ES-2: Summary of Options to Mitigate Impacts to White
Pine County
of the Yucca Mountain Repository
System
|
|
While monitoring is not considered an acceptable mitigation
strategy under NEPA guidelines or from the |
|
|
perspective of White Pine County and the City of Ely, the
unique characteristics of the Yucca Mountain |
|
|
repository and the potential stigma effects confound advance
analysis of all potential impacts. |
|
|
|
Therefore, White Pine County is requesting that DOE
implement comprehensive monitoring programs (or fund |
|
|
White Pine County to implement monitoring programs) of
environmental and socioeconomic changes within |
|
|
the County as a result of the repository. In order for the
monitoring program to serve as a mitigation |
|
|
measure, DOE must commit to necessary actions to mitigate
impacts when (or if) they are detected. |
|
|
Impact Area |
Avoid |
Minimize |
Rectify |
Reduce/Eliminate Over Time |
Compensate |
|
Radiation Exposure |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
Use strategies to reduce stops during transport and insure
that stops are in non-populated areas DOE should improve the safety of the
shipping containers to minimize the likelihood of a release into the
environment in the event of a transport accident Consider the rail only
option as a means of reducing radiation exposure Build a by-pass highway
around the communities of Ely and McGill |
Develop decontamination plan and fund implementation
through trust fund for human and environmental exposure to radiation |
If unacceptable levels of radiation are detected in the
County, implement changes in practices to reduce levels |
Fund White Pine County for staffing and equipment to
implement independent monitoring and oversight of radiation levels. Fund
doctors and medical staff in White Pine County for training to identify and
treat radiation sickness Establish advance commitment to provide
compensation for White Pine County in the event that heightened radiation
levels are detected, due to normal activities or in the event of an accident
that results in a breach of containment |
|
Table ES-2: Page 2 |
|
|
|
|
|
Impact Area |
Avoid |
Minimize |
Rectify |
Reduce/Eliminate Over Time |
Compensate |
|
Employment |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
Overcome stigma through public information and regional
marketing strategy Establish trust fund to enable immediate implementation
of marketing/education strategy |
On-going public information On-going regional marketing
strategy |
(The goal is to maximize job opportunities) Locate
ancillary office functions in White Pine County DOE should commit to local
procurement policies within the State of Nevada and White Pine County
|
|
Income |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
Overcome stigma through public information and regional
marketing strategy Establish trust fund to enable immediate implementation
of marketing/education strategy |
On-going public information On-going regional marketing
strategy |
(The goal is to maximize local income benefits) DOE should
establish procurement policy that would increase purchases of goods and
services from White Pine County Locate ancillary office functions in White
Pine County |
|
Population |
|
Area quality of life initiatives Risk communication and
public education |
|
Table ES-2: Page 3 |
|
|
|
|
|
Impact Area |
Avoid |
Minimize |
Rectify |
Reduce/Eliminate Over Time |
Compensate |
|
Emergency Management |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
Cross training and reciprocal agreements with other
impacted communities and DOE Adhere to strict safety standards and
operating procedures Minimize the time for supporting personnel and
equipment to arrive at the scene of an accident Provide guidance and
insure that community has the appropriate level of training and equipment
Clarify responsibilities in response procedures between federal, state, and
local governments Locate critical or difficult to move equipment in White
Pine County to reduce response times. To the degree that DOE takes
responsibility for emergency management for all incidents involving the
nuclear waste casks this will reduce the overall impact on White Pine County
|
Establish equipment decontamination replacement strategy
Establish emergency response/medical supply replacement strategy Establish
trust fund to allow immediate decontamination and/or replacement of
equipment and supplies |
DOE to implement a continual evaluation (external audit)
of the transport safety procedures and establish improved safety protocols
as the need is identified |
Funding to purchase additional baseline equipment and
equipment for radiological incident Funding for additional staff for
increased non-radiological and radiological incidents Funding for
continuing training in emergency management of radioactive material
Contingency for grants to reimburse the County for costs incurred during any
incident related to repository activity. Funding to develop and publicize
an evacuation plan for the communities. Funding to acquire and operate
emergency notification system Funds to upgrade emergency communication
equipment and ensure that different departments have capability to
communicate with each other |
|
Table ES-2: Page 4 |
|
|
|
|
|
Impact Area |
Avoid |
Minimize |
Rectify |
Reduce/Eliminate Over Time |
Compensate |
|
Emergency Medical |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
Cross training and reciprocal agreements with other
impacted areas and DOE Develop a standard of competency for radiological
medical treatment and ensure that staff meet the minimum requirements
Transport of spent nuclear fuel and high-level waste along routes that avoid
White Pine County |
Establish equipment decontamination and supply replacement
strategy Set up trust fund to allow immediate implementation of
decontamination/resupply strategy |
Funding to purchase additional equipment and hire
additional staff Contingency for grants to reimburse the County for costs
incurred during any incident related to repository activity. On going
radiological training for medical staff Funds to modify hospital to
provide capability for quarantine Funds to develop an evacuation plan for
the hospital and educate staff |
|
Local Oversight |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
DOE to provide information and maintain good communication
with the local oversight staff Strong independent state/NRC oversight
Provide for continued local oversight evaluation |
Provide for continued local oversight evaluation |
Provide for continued local oversight evaluation |
Funding for independent local oversight and monitoring
during site characterization, construction, emplacement, and pre-closure
activity |
|
Local Government Finance |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada Fully fund all fiscal
impacts in advance |
Minimize stigma Reduce lag-time between impact detection
and mitigation implementation |
Develop and implement regional marketing program Budget
supplements for unanticipated expenses |
Develop and implement regional marketing program
|
Grants to local govts. if repository impacts require
additional staff Compensate local governments for capital outlays if
stigma-induced effects reduce population Payments sufficient to cover all
possible recurring impacts (PETT) |
|
Table ES-2: Page 5 |
|
|
|
|
|
Impact Area |
Avoid |
Minimize |
Rectify |
Reduce/Eliminate Over Time |
Compensate |
|
Highway Transportation Accident Risk |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
Special lanes for trucks Lead and follow cars Special
warning lights and signs Elimination of at grade railroad crossings on
public roads and highways Special signage on private railroad crossings
Restrictions on truck movements in inclement weather and over Murry Summit
DOE should evaluate the safety characteristics of the two-lane roads that
may be utilized DOE should fund and staff a weather monitoring and
communicatin system to advise transport operators and County staff Lane
separation on Murry Summit Build a by-pass highway around Ely and McGill
Enhanced winter road condition maintenance |
Local control and management participation in accident
assessments Highway upgrades and enhanced maintenance |
Monitor for accidents and adjust safety procedures to
eliminate additional risk DOE to implement a continual evaluation
(external audit) of the transport safety procedures and to modify protocols
as the need is identified |
Funding for the County to cover costs of any safety
mechanisms that DOE does not implement directly Contingency for grants to
reimburse the County for costs incurred during any incident related to
repository activity. |
|
Table ES-2: Page 6 |
|
|
|
|
|
Impact Area |
Avoid |
Minimize |
Rectify |
Reduce/Eliminate Over Time |
Compensate |
|
Tourism |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
Maintain impeccable safety record for the repository
system Develop and implement risk communication plan Develop and
implement on-going regional marketing strategy Area quality of life
initiatives |
Maintain impeccable safety record at the repository and
the intermodal facility Enhanced risk communication Enhanced regional
marketing initiatives Area quality of life initiatives |
Maintain impeccable safety record for the repository
system Sustained education and risk communication campaign Sustained
regional marketing initiatives Area quality of life initiatives |
Grants to White Pine County to fund advertisements and to
enhance marketing plans A contingency agreement to compensate White Pine
County in the event that tourism is affected due to the repository system |
|
Economic Development |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
DOE policy that favors White Pine County for purchase of
minerals and finished products Establish satellite offices for the
repository in White Pine County Maintain impeccable safety record at the
repository and the intermodal facility Develop and implement risk
communication plan Develop and implement on-going regional marketing
strategy |
Maintain impeccable safety record at the repository and
the intermodal facility Maintain impeccable safety record at the
repository and the intermodal facility Enhanced risk communication
Enhanced regional marketing initiatives |
Maintain impeccable safety record at the repository and
the intermodal facility Sustained education and risk communication
campaign Sustained regional marketing initiatives |
A contingency agreement to compensate White Pine County if
businesses that were planning on locating in the County reverse their
decision based on the repository system A contingency agreement to
compensate White Pine County if immigrants that were planning on locating in
the County reverse their decision based on the repository system |
|
Table ES-2: Page 7 |
|
|
|
|
|
Impact Area |
Avoid |
Minimize |
Rectify |
Reduce/Eliminate Over Time |
Compensate |
|
Real Property |
Do not construct and operate interim storage or permanent
radioactive waste disposal capability in Nevada |
Maintain impeccable safety record for the repository
system Develop and implement risk communication plan Develop and
implement regional marketing plan Develop and implement property
enhancement plan DOE investments in community assets |
Maintain impeccable safety record at the repository and
the intermodal facility Develop and implement property enhancement plan
DOE investment in community assets |
Maintain impeccable safety record at the repository and
the intermodal facility Develop and implement property enhancement plan
DOE investments in community assets |
Establish pre-project property value data-base and monitor
for changes in property values along the transport corridor Compensation
for property owners along transportation routes and throughout the community
if property values decline due to repository system |